I agree about s3. The stories and the overarching theme were really intricately done, and even despite the things that annoyed me about what the writers did, I do like the openly complicated Ten/Martha dynamic. And I like dark, so the series' darkness, I ate it up. Also, I pretty much think Ten's characterization was an interesting and natural progression for the Doctor. I'd like to see him move on through it, but still.

But I also love series 1, because it was tightly put together and it had Nine in it, and he had a sort of centered gravitas that brought everything together, even through the occasional devolutions into camp (and I'm an old school lover, so why would that bit bother me?). Basically, it's just s2 that was sadly weak for me.